No Session Today
View all rates
Beginner3 min readThe Economy and Saving in Egypt · 8/13

Mutual Funds or Buying Stocks Directly: What Is the Difference?

You can reach the stock market two ways: buy shares yourself, or buy units in an equity fund and let a manager choose for you. Neither is always better; each has its price and its advantage.

What you will learn

  • Tell the two routes apart: who decides, diversification, costs and exit.
  • Work out how one falling stock hits a concentrated and a spread portfolio.
  • Know what diversification does not protect you from.
In this lesson

Two routes to the same market

When you buy a share yourself, you pick the company, decide when to buy and sell, and follow its news. When you buy units in an equity fund, the investment manager picks and monitors according to the fund's policy, and you own a slice of the whole portfolio. This lesson covers open-end funds, whose units you buy and redeem at NAV.

Your own shares
Equity fund
Who decides what to buy?
You
The manager, per the fund's policy
Diversification
As wide as the shares you buy
Spread across many holdings, per its policy
Costs
Commission and fees on each trade
Management fees taken from the fund, and possibly subscription or redemption fees
Exit
Sell during the session if a buyer is there, at the executed market price
Redeem at NAV on the prospectus dates
The same market, but decisions, diversification, costs and exit differ.

Diversification in numbers

Invented numbers to illustrateYou have EGP 20,000. Split across two shares, 10,000 each, if one falls 40% you lose 4,000, or 20% of your money. An invented fund spread over 20 shares at 5% each: if the same share falls 40%, the hit to the fund is about 5% × 40% = 2%, if the other shares do not move.

That is what diversification does: it softens the effect of one company's trouble. You can do the same yourself by buying many shares, but that takes more money, time and monitoring, and every trade carries a commission. A fund gives you that spread with a smaller amount; in return you pay management fees and leave the choices to someone else.

Costs and exit

With direct shares, you pay commission and fees on every buy and sell, so the more you trade, the more you pay. In a fund, management fees come out of the fund every year, good year or bad, and there may be subscription or redemption fees. On exit, a share is sold during the session if a buyer is there, at the executed market price, and in a thinly traded share an order may not fill or may fill at a different price. A unit is redeemed at NAV on the dates the prospectus sets, so you may not know the exact price when you ask.

Watch outIf the whole market falls, an equity fund will most likely be affected too, to a degree that depends on its holdings: diversification reduces single-company risk but does not remove market risk. And a manager's past record does not guarantee beating the market later.

Compare for yourself

The funds page shows unit values and performance, and the stocks list shows companies if you prefer to choose yourself.

Check yourself

1. A portfolio holds two shares at equal weight; one falls 30% and the other does not move. How much did the portfolio fall?

Half the portfolio fell 30%, so the effect is 50% × 30% = 15%.

2. A widely diversified equity fund, and the whole market falls 20%. What most likely happened to the fund?

Diversification cuts single-company risk, not whole-market risk.

Summary

  • With direct shares you decide; in a fund the manager decides per its policy.
  • A fund gives you spread with a small amount, in return for management fees and exit at NAV.
  • Diversification softens single-company hits but not a whole-market fall.

Related terms

Related lessons

Educational content only, not investment advice. Companies and figures in the examples are invented for illustration.